Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Do you think Gandhi is responsible for the tragic end of his eldest son, Harilal?





In my opinion, Gandhi was succeed in his life work which is to promote non-violence and reuniting other people in India. Gandhi or his true name, Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi had started to let India to be independence and inspired movements for non-violence, civil rights and freedom across the world. 

He had fight for the civil rights of Muslim and Hindu Indians in South Africa and he became famous. In his speech in front of Muslim and Hindu Indians, he told them that he wanted them to fight, not to provoke. He also told them never attack back to the British even they had do bad to them. It will pay by God, not by them. 

                                      



Besides that, Gandhi was able to reunite the people in India which is Hindu and Muslim. They had tolerated to stop the war become worst and distract others in India. It happened when Gandhi was fasting for one day to stop the war. Furthermore, some Indians are giving their weapons to Gandhi in order to stop the war between them and Muslim.

As a conclusion, Gandhi was not failed to promote non-violence and reuniting other people in India. He transformed the people in India become more responsible for their country and lives in peace. 

6 comments:

  1. For my opinion, i don't think that gandhi succeed because still the hindu and the muslim are still fighting even after they reach independence.However, gandhi is still a great man

    ReplyDelete
  2. for me, i also think gandhi was failure to unite the indian people. you can see when pakistan and india still fighting each other until today

    ReplyDelete
  3. you don't give your opinion regarding the tragic end for Gandhi son, isn't it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. yeah...I have noticed about it..poor Harilal..

    ReplyDelete
  5. i totally agree with acap and anis :) but Gandhi was a great leader and father of India!

    ReplyDelete
  6. i would say that gandhi has succeed.. why? success cant be claimed to others. if Gandhi has done his utmost role to unite the people, then i would consider it as success. the failures were the native Indian because they themselves dont want to change. a person who dont want to change to be better is the failure but gandhi is not a failure.

    in addition, i think you have committed red herring because you were not answering the question

    ReplyDelete